Our Story

An East End Institution

The Seafood Shop

For over four decades, The Seafood Shop has been the Wainscott stop for fresh fish and honest takeout. What started as a simple fish market on Montauk Highway grew into the East End's go-to for day-boat seafood, hot lobster rolls, and legendary clambakes.

We still do it the old way: buy the best fish available that morning, cut it right, cook it fresh, and treat every customer like a neighbor — because most of you are.

By the Numbers

Why Wainscott Chooses Us

0
Seafood Varieties Daily
0
Years on Montauk Hwy
0
Stop for Clambakes

* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration.

Kind Words

Guests Love It Here

★★★★★
“The lobster roll is the real deal and the fish case is always beautiful. We stop every single weekend.”
— Local, Wainscott
★★★★★
“Ordered a clambake for 30 people — flawless. Everything arrived hot and on time.”
— Host, East Hampton
★★★★★
“Best shrimp cocktail platter on the East End, full stop.”
— Customer, Southampton
Proudly Serving

The East End & Beyond

Ready When You Are

Call, email, or stop by — we'd love to see you at The Seafood Shop.

📞 Call Now 📍 Directions